Irrational Reading - Issue 3

Even if such a today soon ceases to be today, no one can deny that it is in fact a today. For if a today ceased to be today, history could not exist as history. - Haruki Murakami, A Wild Sheep Chase

Irrational Reading


Issue 3

Mar 24 2025

Another week, another chance to get lost in a great story. I’ve loved seeing your thoughts and reflections on this month’s book, and today we’ll close the loop with a few final questions and resources that might deepen your appreciation even more.

Current Book: A Wild Sheep Chase

Week 4: We've finished this month's book!

Recap

During our last discussion, we spoke about the surreal quality of the book so far and how it contributes to feelings of detachment and isolation, along with a sense of disillusionment. We talked about the theme of possession and the idea of being possessed by something — a person, an idea, or a place. We also had some great insights from our members into the symbolism of the sheep, exploring what it might represent — power, freedom, identity, or something else entirely.

I loved to hear your thoughts on how the different locations in the book — the city, the mountains, the hotel — reflect the narrator's inner journey and the changes he undergoes throughout the story. Was this intentional on Murakami's part, or are we reading too much into it?

In the final sections of the book, one of the central themes — individual identity and autonomy — comes to the forefront, and the surreal elements of the story are brought to a head in the final chapters. The ambiguity of the ending leaves us with more questions than answers. The Rat’s story and his relationship with the narrator were particularly poignant, and I’m curious to hear your thoughts on how their dynamic played out.

Discussion Questions

Ahead of our final meeting about A Wild Sheep Chase, here are a few questions to consider as you reflect on the book.

  • What do you think the sheep ultimately represents?
  • How do you interpret the idea of possession or being possessed?
  • How did the relationship with the women with the magical ears impact the narrator?
  • What do you think the novel is trying to say about the idea of searching for answers in a world that offers none?
  • What did you think of the Rat’s decision in the end?
  • How did you feel about the ambiguous ending — satisfying or frustrating? Why?

Support us on Patreon

With a small contribution, you can help us continue to produce this newsletter and grow our community. You will also get access to the Irrational Reading Bookclub Meetings where we discuss what we're reading and share our thoughts.

Beyond the Book

The Labyrinth and the Non-Solution

Rhys William Tyers

In the journal article The Labyrinth and the Non-Solution: Murakami’s A Wild Sheep Chase and the Metaphysical, Rhys William Tyers examines how Haruki Murakami’s novel fits into the metaphysical detective genre.

A Wild Sheep Chase

Glynne Walley's J-lit site

A very interesting post about the symbolism of the sheep and how it represents a desire for unity and strength through surrendering one’s identity to a larger cause, which can be seen as a critique of ideologies like fascism that emphasize collective unity over individual identity.

Murakami’s Farewell to Despair

Lowry Pei

This article analyzes Haruki Murakami’s early novels, Hear the Wind Sing and Pinball, 1973, as a prelude to his later work, particularly A Wild Sheep Chase. The article emphasizes the role of female characters in breaking the protagonist’s passivity and enabling him to access untapped parts of himself, ultimately leading to fuller communication and a more profound exploration of human emotions.

Next Meeting

Our next book club meeting will take place on March 24. Members, keep an eye on your inbox—we’ll be sending out the meeting link via email. If you're not yet a member and interested in joining the first meeting is free of charge.

Next Read

We’re switching gears and getting back to reality for our spring read. I’m excited to announce that our next book club pick is Slow Productivity: The Lost Art of Accomplishment Without Burnout by Cal Newport. This book challenges the conventional notion of productivity, which often leads to burnout and pseudo-productivity.

Newport argues that our current approach to productivity is flawed, placing too much emphasis on busyness rather than meaningful work. He proposes a more sustainable alternative - what he calls “slow productivity,” inspired by the Slow Food movement — focused on deep work, deliberate practice, and the pursuit of mastery.

We're going to approach the reading schedule a bit more slowly this time around, with roughly a chapter a week to give us time to reflect on the ideas and put them into practice. I'm looking forward to diving into this book with you all!

Reading Schedule: Slow Productivity

Week 1

Introduction & Chapters 1-2

Week 2

Chapter 3

Week 3

Chapter 4

Week 4

Chapter 5 & Conclusion