IR / NEWSLETTER 17

Crying in H Mart

Crying in H Mart — Michelle Zauner

Hi everyone,

Welcome to issue 17 of Irrational Reading! It’s been over a year since I sent the last one, so this may be the first to land in your inbox. I’m glad you’re here. You can catch up on past issues in the archive

What we’re reading

Last night we spent an hour on the first six chapters of Michelle Zauner’s Crying in H Mart. We kept coming back to Michelle’s mother, Chongmi. When she packs Michelle a lunch exactly the way she likes it, the love is easy to see. We had a harder time agreeing about the moments when she criticizes Michelle’s choices or keeps things to herself. At what point does looking out for your daughter become trying to run her life?

One thing we did agree on was that knowing from the first page that Chongmi dies makes the ordinary scenes land harder. Even a packed lunch feels different once you know how much Michelle will miss it.

Here’s the plan for the rest of the book:

You can also find the full reading plan on Patreon.

Three questions for November 26

  1. When Michelle tries to find something her mother can eat, do you get the sense she also has something to prove?
  2. Which of their arguments would you most like to hear Chongmi tell in her own words?
  3. Was there a food scene that told you something about Michelle and Chongmi you wouldn’t have picked up from their conversations?

Bring whichever question gets you talking. Or bring your own, which is usually better.

What we just read

On November 12, we met to talk about Sayaka Murata’s Convenience Store Woman. Keiko is good at her job. She likes it there. So why is it so hard for the people around her to take her at her word?

That led us to a question a little closer to home. When we say we want better for someone, how much of that is about their happiness and how much of it is about our own discomfort with their choices?

Beyond the book

Next

I’ll write when we have a book to talk about, which at our pace is roughly once a month. If someone forwarded you this issue, you can sign up for the next one here

And if there’s something about either book you’d rather write than say out loud, just hit reply. It comes straight to me.

Jordan


← All issues