Irrational Reading Logo

Better a live donkey than a dead lion. -
Earnest Shackleton

Irrational Reading


Issue 11

May 26 2025

After reading about the journey of the Endurance, I cannot stop thinking about the incredible resilience of the crew. I'm amazed when people don't complain after being stuck in a traffic jam for 10 minutes let alone on ice for almost two years! This story is a testament to human endurance and the power of positive thinking. It seemed the greatest danger was not the harsh Antarctic conditions, but the potential for despair and hopelessness to take hold. In times of extreme stress, the crew's ability to maintain a sense of purpose and camaraderie was crucial for their survival. Shackleton's leadership style, which emphasized the importance of morale and teamwork, played a significant role in keeping the crew focused and motivated.

Current Read: Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage

The expedition is over and the book is finished! Our next adventure awaits!

The crew pulling the James Caird across the ice The crew pulling the James Caird across the ice


The storytelling in "Endurance" is captivating, with vivid descriptions of the harsh Antarctic landscape and the crew's struggles against the elements. The book does an excellent job of bringing the reader into the heart of the expedition, allowing us to experience the challenges and triumphs alongside Shackleton and his crew. Lansing also does a remarkable job of capturing the personalities of the crew members, making them feel like real people rather than just names in a history book. Their camaraderie, humor, and resilience shine through. I'm really looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the book and the expedition.

Discussion Questions

  • What specific decisions or actions stood out to you as pivotal for their survival?
  • How did the men cope with the monotony and psychological strain of waiting for rescue on Elephant Island?
  • Were there any descriptions of the landscape or weather that particularly struck you?
  • What lessons from this story of endurance and leadership can be applied to challenges in everyday life?
  • Which crew member’s story or perspective resonated with you the most, and why?

Support us on Patreon

With a small contribution, you can help us continue to produce this newsletter and grow our community. You will also get access to the Irrational Reading Bookclub Meetings where we discuss what we're reading and share our thoughts.

Beyond the Book

Historical Map tracking the Endurance

RareMaps.com

A highly detailed historical map showing the track of the Endurance and the subsequent boat journeys, as well as the rescue efforts

Expedition Timeline and Overview

Royal Geographical Society

The Royal Geographical Society provides a timeline and historical overview of the expedition, outlining significant milestones and hardships faced by the crew

Discovering Antarctica

discoveringantarctica.org.uk

Discovering Antarctica: Background on the rise of whaling in South Georgia, the establishment of shore stations, and the economic and environmental consequences.

Next Meeting

Our next book club meeting will take place on May 27. Members, keep an eye on your inbox—we’ll be sending out the meeting link via email. If you're not yet a member and interested in joining the first meeting is free of charge.